Miss Nelly wearing a chef's outfit with a name tag on a white background

The Daily Bark

News you can sink your teeth into!

Jerky Dog Treats vs Dog Biscuits: Which Is Healthier for Overweight Dogs?

Smiling girl with happy golden retriever giving him pieces of Miss Nelly's jerky treats

Oh, those big, hopeful eyes! We all love spoiling our dogs with treats — it’s one of the sweetest parts of being a dog parent. A little something special just because they’re so good (or simply because we adore them). But here’s the gentle truth: for so many pups, those extra snacks are quietly adding up and contributing to weight gain more than we realize. I know my own dog has me trained to share all my food with her with just a slight head tilt and side eye!

According to the Association for Pet Obesity Prevention (APOP), about 59% of dogs in the United States were classified as overweight or obese in their 2022 survey — a number that still rings true for many loving pet parents today. 

Are jerky treats healthier than dog biscuits?

Jerky dog treats made primarily from real meat often contain more protein and fewer fillers than traditional biscuits. Because they can be broken into smaller pieces, they also allow much better calorie control during training and daily rewards — making them a smarter choice for dogs who need to watch their weight.

In This Article
• Are dog treats causing weight gain?
• How to tell if your dog is overweight
• Jerky vs biscuits: calorie and ingredient comparison
• Why high-protein treats help with weight control
• Healthier treat choices and training tips
• Common questions about dog treats

Are Dog Treats Causing Weight Gain?

Yes — especially if they’re the traditional high-calorie biscuits loaded with grains and fillers. Even a few extra treats a day can quietly add up and tip the scales over weeks and months.

How to Tell If Your Dog Is Overweight

It’s actually really easy to check at home using the Body Condition Score. Here’s a simple way to do it:

- Gently run your hands along your dog’s ribs — you should be able to feel them with just a light layer of fat (like the back of your hand).
- Look down from above — there should be a nice, visible “hourglass” waist behind the ribs.
- From the side — you should see a tucked tummy (not a rounded belly).

If the ribs are hard to feel, the waist has disappeared, or your dog looks a bit round from the side, they’re probably carrying extra weight. Even being just 10% over their ideal weight can affect their comfort and long-term health.

Jerky vs Biscuits: A Simple Calorie and Ingredient Comparison

Let’s look at a friendly side-by-side to see how much difference the right choice can make for your pup’s waistline and happiness:

Jerky vs Biscuits: A Simple Comparison

Feature Real Meat Jerky (Miss Nelly’s) Traditional Crunchy Dog Biscuits Why It Matters
Main Ingredient Real meat (~85%) Grains and fillers Higher-quality protein keeps dogs fuller longer
Protein Content High Moderate Better satiety and muscle support
Fillers & Carbohydrates Minimal High Fewer empty calories = easier weight control
Fats & Preservatives No synthetic BHA/BHT Often includes beef fat + synthetic additives Avoids controversial preservatives
Texture Soft & chewy Hard & crunchy Easier to eat, especially for seniors
Training Use Easy to tear into small pieces Hard to portion Perfect for frequent low-calorie rewards

The Wild Game treats are perfect for training because the jerky pieces come in one inch squares. The perfect treat portion done for you.

Why High-Protein Treats Help With Weight Control

Dogs feel fuller and more satisfied with protein-rich snacks like real meat jerky. This natural satiety can help prevent overeating compared with carbohydrate-heavy biscuits that often leave dogs still looking for more. High-protein treats support lean muscle while making it easier to stay within the recommended 10% daily calorie limit for treats.

Try Real Meat Jerky Treats from Miss Nelly’s

If you’re looking for a healthier alternative to traditional biscuits, real meat jerky treats can provide higher protein and fewer fillers while allowing better portion control. Nothing satisfies like that real roasted meat flavor!

Popular options from Miss Nelly’s include:

Beef Jerky Dog Treats 
Chicken Jerky Dog Treats  
Wild Game Elk & Venison Treats 

Miss Nelly’s Canine Gourmet has been producing USA-made jerky dog treats since 2012. Trusted by thousands of dog owners, our slow-smoked treats are proudly made and sourced 100% in the USA with USDA-inspected meats and simple, wholesome ingredients — no MSG, corn, soy, wheat, grain, gluten, or fillers.

Because the pieces tear easily, they’re ideal as low-calorie training treats, letting you reward good behavior more often without adding too many calories.

 Easy, Loving Tips for Smarter Treat Time

1. Stick to the 10% rule — Keep treats to no more than 10% of your dog’s daily calories.  
2. Choose quality over quantity — Break jerky pieces into smaller bits for more tasty moments.  
3. Swap smartly — Replace higher-calorie biscuits with Miss Nelly’s lower-calorie jerky.  
4. Add movement — Pair treat time with walks or play.  
5. Check in regularly — Monitor your dog’s body condition monthly.

Common Questions About Dog Treats

How many treats should a dog have per day? 

Most veterinarians recommend keeping treats under 10% of daily calories.

Are jerky treats healthier than dog biscuits?

Yes — they usually offer more protein, fewer fillers, and better portion control.

Can treats cause dogs to gain weight? 

Yes, if they exceed the calorie allowance. Breakable, high-protein jerky helps you stay in control.

Are jerky treats good for training?  

Absolutely — especially ones that tear easily into small pieces.

*As always, consult your veterinarian about your dog’s specific needs.

Want to check your breeds feeding guidelines? Look here.

Try Miss Nelly’s Real-Meat Jerky Treats
Shop the full collection now

Related Treat Collections:
Beef Jerky Dog Treats  
Chicken Jerky Dog Treats  
Training Treats for Dogs  
Limited Ingredient Treats  

Worried your dog is a picky eater? Miss Nelly's offers a 100% money back guarantee. Once you try Miss Nelly's you will never look back – tail wags assured!

–The Miss Nelly's Team

Sources* 
Association for Pet Obesity Prevention (APOP) 2022 U.S. State of Pet Obesity Report.

Comments

Leave a comment

Be the first to leave a comment
    Pattern of dog bones and paw prints on a red background

    JOIN THE PACK

    SUBSCRIBE AND GET FREE SHIPPING OVER $30.

    Stay updated with our latest news, exclusive offers, and delicious new treats for your furry friends!

    Sign Up Now